Doom
| Relationship | Randy is a fan and retrospective commentator. He says he became a Doom fan in 1995, played multiple versions across platforms, and repeatedly compares those versions in his videos. |
|---|---|
| Sentiment | Mixed |
| Assessment | Randy praises Doom as one of the greatest video games ever made and calls some versions amazing, but he also criticizes specific ports and design choices, especially the Super Nintendo and PC episode structure. |
Doom is a first-person shooter video game that Randy Charles Johnson discusses as a favorite he has followed across multiple platforms. He says he became a Doom fan in 1995 and later compared the Sega 32X, PlayStation, Atari Jaguar, Game Boy Advance, 3DO, PC, and Super Nintendo versions.
Randy's overall view is positive, but not uncritical. He calls Doom one of the greatest video games ever made, while also arguing that some ports are much weaker than others.
Randy's view
Randy presents Doom as a landmark game and says he first encountered it on the Sega 32X before becoming a fan. He also defends the game against the claim that it is a murder simulator, saying the player shoots demons and zombies rather than committing murder.
Version comparisons
A major theme in Randy's commentary is how different versions handle progression. He prefers the PlayStation version because it preserves more of the original game without forcing the player to restart with lost equipment after each episode, and he says the PC version is more frustrating in that respect.
He is especially harsh on the Super Nintendo port, which he says has worse graphics, bad controls, and extra difficulty restrictions. By contrast, he calls the Sony PS1 version amazing and says it is the best console version he played.
Related articles
Source note: The evidence clearly supports Doom as the video game Randy is discussing. The transcript wording varies a little across videos, but the core claims about the game, its ports, and Randy's preferences are consistent.
References
- Randy Johnson, 30th Anniversary of Doom (randy commentary), archived transcript.
- Randy Johnson, Sony PS1 Doom VS. PC Doom (randy commentary), archived transcript.
- Randy Johnson, DOOM: The Greatest Video Game (randy commentary), archived transcript.