Superman II
| Relationship | Randy says he bought the theatrical DVD, calls the film his favorite of the four Superman movies, and discusses why he prefers the theatrical version over the Richard Donner cut. |
|---|---|
| Sentiment | Positive |
| Assessment | Randy is broadly favorable toward Superman II itself: he calls it his favorite of the four Superman movies and says his preferred version is the theatrical release, even though he criticizes some choices in the Donner cut. |
Superman II is the film Randy Charles Johnson reviews in the source video. He says he bought the theatrical DVD, calls it his favorite of the four Superman movies, and compares it with the Richard Donner cut.
Version Comparison
Randy prefers the theatrical release, but he also discusses the Richard Donner cut. His main criticism is that it repeats the time-reversal ending and leaves him thinking the powers-restoration scene is handled better in the other version.
Specific Complaints
He says the trucker-revenge scene makes no sense after the time reversal, and he thinks the theatrical cut should have explained more clearly how Superman gets his powers back.
Related articles
Source note: The transcript clearly supports Randy's preference for the theatrical cut and his criticism of the Richard Donner cut. The only notable uncertainty is his memory that he first saw the film in 1981, which is not fully reliable against the film's usual release history.
References
- Randy Johnson, Superman II on DVD," YouTube (randy commentary), archived transcript.